“ My wife and I came here the other evening. It was my first time coming, and her second time ever being here. We wanted wings, and years ago, when this place opened, they used to have a wing challenge. Unfortunately, that is no longer in effect. You can, however, get their scorpion sauce (for an extra 3), which is the sauce used for the challenge in the past. Anyhow. Cayla was our server, and she was absolutely great. Very friendly, super helpful and informative, and patient as we decided what we wanted. Throughout the meal, she did a wonderful job of being attentive without being overbearing or intrusive. Together, we got 20 wings and a basket of fries, as well as a Buffalo chicken dip for an appetizer. We got our toddler Mac n' cheese and some cooked veggies. I got the scorpion sauce and spicy garlic teriyaki, and my wife got the peppery Polynesian and BBQ. The wings were crips and freshly cooked. All the sauces were good on the wings. The scorpion sauce is extremely hot, not for the faint of heart or beginners, but for a real chili head, they have a great flavor without any extract taste. The teriyaki garlic wings were a great way to cool down the heat of the other wings and have a sticky sweet heat to them. The Polynesian sauce was sweet, and according to my wife, "Had a little heat." The BBQ tasted like basic, run of the mill BBQ, but no complaints on those. Fries were hot and crispy. Restaurant and bathrooms were clean. All around was a good experience, albeit a bit pricey. I can see us coming back here again, and I would definitely recommend this place. They have a great variety of foods and sauces for their wings. ”

“ Island Wing Company, located at 1370 Market St, Tallahassee, FL 32312, is hands down one of the best restaurants I have ever been to. The chicken wings are simply amazing! They are high-quality, consistent, and cooked to perfection every time. What I love most about this restaurant is the wide range of sauces and rubs that they offer for the chicken wings. Whether you prefer spicy or mild, sweet or tangy, there is a flavor that is sure to please your taste buds. And the best part is that the sauces and rubs are made fresh daily, so you can always count on getting the best possible flavor. The wait staff at Island Wing Company is also incredibly warm and friendly, making you feel right at home from the moment you walk through the door. They are attentive to your needs and always go above and beyond to ensure that you have a great dining experience. In addition to the chicken wings, the restaurant also offers a great selection of sides, appetizers, and drinks. And the atmosphere is welcoming and cozy, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal. Overall, I highly recommend Island Wing Company to anyone who loves great chicken wings and a warm, friendly dining experience. This restaurant is truly top-notch and deserves a glowing review and a top rating. If you're in the area, don't miss out on this gem of a restaurant! ”

“ Island wing co. has some of the best wings in Tallahassee with there wide variety of flavors and sauces. We came out tonight for my sisters birthday and the atmosphere was absolutely perfect! I loved the outside seating.. Gave off a island style resort vibe. The service was outstanding, thank you Amanda and the drinks were perfect. We had a few apps to share starting with the real tuna fish salad not caned, the coconut shrimp were grilled as well as the fries.. Not a fan there. The burger slider and sausage sliders were very good. The chicken nachos were really great.. Gave off a nice smokey flavor. The cheese sticks were average or standard. The fish tacos were perfect but the rice was just ok but over all we had an amazing time so we will return soon. ”

“ Decent experience. Food was good. Service was ok. No drinks got a refill unless asked. Overall great time and I would return. ”

“ So I took my guy friend out to eat here one Thursday and he enjoyed every bit of it from being to enjoy the fire pit to the drinks. Food was exceptionally good which the night ended very well. Will suggest to other friends and family. ”

“ Two of us got the boneless wings. We both love the sauces we chose! We eat baked fries at home, but I was a little reluctant to get them at a restaurant. I was pleasantly surprised because the baked fries were delicious. We would definitely come back. ”

“ This was my first time actually eating in the restaurant and the food was so amazing and full of flavor. I feel like the waiters were mediocre though but otherwise I loved it! I had the mahi entree with reggae rice & steamed veggies. ”

“ Like this place but last two times food disappointed. This time tried a healthy veggies stir fry. Would have been perfect but waaaay too much sauce. Maybe with meat the sauce is popular...but as health conscious please consider less (unhealthy) sauce on veggies. We don't like sauces on side, especially in plastics, but maybe use less and only give a side for those few request it. ”